Florida's Anti-Voter Law Violates Free Speech, Court Rules
Federal Judge Overturns Requirement That Voter Registration Groups Give Misleading Information
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. – Today a federal court sided with Harriett Tubman Freedom Fighters (HTFF) in HTFF v. Laurel Lee, ruling that Florida’s S.B. 90 infringed on its right to free speech when the state forced the organization to make false claims to potential voters while trying to help them register. U.S. District Court Judge Mark E. Walker ruled in three cases consolidated with HTFF v. Lee, mandating that Florida seek pre-clearance from the court for changes to voting laws that would restrict dropboxes, voting by mail, 3rd Party Voter Registration Organizations, or assisting other voters in the next 10 years under Section 3c of the Voting Rights Act. HTFF is represented by Fair Elections Center, The Southern Poverty Law Center, and Baker McKenzie.
“The court has delivered a victory for voting rights organizations over new barriers to community voter registration drives created last year by Governor Ron DeSantis and Florida state legislators,” said Michelle Kanter Cohen, policy director and senior counsel with Fair Elections Center. “This decision vindicates the critical role of building community trust in voting and political participation that our client and other organizations fill. The ruling has established S.B. 90 violates our client’s freedom of speech, and we call on Florida’s legislature and governor to stop enacting barrier to Floridians’ making their voices heard in our democracy.”
“We applaud the decision of the court to strike down forced speech provisions, enshrine voting rights and to establish protections for Voting rights in Florida under pre-clearance,” said Caren Short, interim deputy legal director for Voting Rights with SPLC. “We have been proud to work alongside allies like the League of Women Voters, the Florida State Conference of the NAACP, and Florida Rising in challenging barriers to voting, and we will continue standing with them and Florida communities against barriers to voting.
Debra Dandeneau, partner at Baker McKenzie said, “We were proud to lend our pro bono time, energy and talent to this victory for voting rights organizations and their freedom of speech.”
Upon hearing the ruling, HTTF President and Co-founder Rosemary McCoy reaffirmed her commitment to voting rights. “We founded HTFF to defend the voice of our community, so we are proud that our right to make our voices heard through organizing and free speech have been affirmed by today’s ruling,” McCoy said. “However, organizations like HTFF are still needed to defend our communities’ right to vote, and we plan to redouble our efforts to empower our community to vote.”
Harriett Tubman Freedom Fighters, Corp., is a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization that focuses voter registration efforts on new voters, particularly youth, communities of color, and returning citizens. The state of Florida compelled HTFF and similar organizations to communicate a false state-sponsored message, at a specific time, to a specific audience when registering new voters. Fair Elections Center, and SPLC filed litigation on behalf of HTFF on June 14 2021, alleging that the new law is void for vagueness under the due process clause of the 14th Amendment, compelled speech in violation of the First Amendment and prevents organizations from exercising their First Amendment rights of expression and association.
The case was consolidated for trial with these others:
League of Women Voters of Florida, Inc. et al. v. Lee et al.
Argued that S.B. 90’s drop box restrictions, mail-in ballot repeat request requirement, volunteer assistance ban, deceptive registration warning and food and water ban violate the First and 14th Amendments.
Florida State Conference of Branches and Youth Units of NAACP et al. v. Lee et al.
Argued that S.B. 90 creates unnecessary barriers and burdens that disproportionately impact of Black and Latinx voters, and voters with disabilities, violating Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act, the First, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution, and Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Florida Rising Together et al. v. Lee et al.
Challenged S.B. 90’s limitations of the availability of drop boxes, addition of identification requirements to request a vote-by-mail ballot, prohibition of assistance to voters waiting in long lines, and imposition of new restrictions on third-party voter registration organizations
For documents, filings and decisions in HTFF v. Lee, please visit: https://www.splcenter.org/seeking-justice/case-docket/harriet-tubman-freedom-fighters-corp-et-al-v-laurel-lee-et-al